Grimsley Afterword PaulGreenplay
Afterword
to Paul Green's The House of Connelly, a Critical Edition, edited by Margaret D. Bauer, published by McFarland, 2014
by JIM GRIMSLEY
Paul Green’s The House of Connelly was a work unknown to me until I was introduced to the script and movie adaptation by Margaret D. Bauer. Being a North Carolina native, I was familiar with Green’s outdoor dramas, the spectacles of history that have made his name something of a household word in my home state. These are strong, solid works of theater, rooted in regional history, adequate to their purpose but hardly daring. Because of them, I thought of Green as a mildly interesting historian, not as a dramatist who made much of an impact, and I certainly would not have associated him with the Group Theater and its legendary, even transformative work.
I am admitting my ignorance of Paul Green’s true body of work, the plays of harder, edgier construction, that brought him to the attention of New York, which is, for good or ill, the capital of American theater.
When Bauer told me about this play, comparing it favorably with the works of Tennessee Williams, the essential Southern playwright, I confess that I was skeptical of her assessment. Williams is a towering figure, probably the most significant American playwright before August Wilson, at least in my estimation. How could Green be spoken of as his peer?
A reading of the play quickly convinced me that I needed to reassess Green altogether, and I understood Bauer’s enthusiasm.
While I doubt I will ever have much to complain about in discussing Williams, I found The House of Connelly to be honest, direct, and powerful in confronting aspects of the South and its heritage, in areas of subject in which Williams, for one reason or another, is more timid. I admire Williams for his hothouse language, his dialog as floridly scented as any magnolia; but I cannot recall a Williams play in which he wrote about the doom at the heart of the South. Issues of race are coded in Williams; in Green’s play, the fact of slavery and the inheritance of white supremacy are exposed like the rawest nerves. In the work of Williams, the plantation is a fading memory. In The House of Connelly, it is the star of the play, and its pivotal place in the drama of Southern history is starkly and bleakly represented.
The play is only a little less concerned with history, and even pageantry, than Green’s better known works, but in Connelly the presentation is more personal, focused as it is on the decay of a family and the people around them. What we witness is a plantation falling to ruins, an agrarian way of life that is dying, and a people who are gripped by the talons of a deadly past. History has turned malevolent in this play, and the shadow it casts on the present is poisonous.
That shadow is drawn quite directly, in explicit terms. As Bauer points out so well in her analysis of the play, the crossing of the forbidden zone between black and white, the presence of miscegenation, lies at the heart of the work. The word itself, miscegenation, is an ugly term for the fact that blacks and whites shared intimacy and produced children throughout the long, cruel night of slavery and its aftermath. The fact of this congress made a lie of the slave owner’s laws against such pairings and offered a human rebuttal to the fiction of difference between what we call the two races, ignoring the science that tells us black and white people are no more different than black or white dogs.
The fact that the elder living Connelly has dallied with black women, the descendants of former family slaves, lies at the heart of the play, and this revelation is the point at which the drama tips into tragedy. In the face of this knowledge, the family crumbles, the elder Connelly kills himself, and the family legacy, that ruined house, sighs and sinks further toward oblivion.
One cannot credit Green’s vision with real enlightenment; he struggles with his vision and, perhaps, yearns for that past world of Connelly wealth and glory in ways that we will question today. As in Faulkner, his African Americans are troubling portraits, presented as wily by nature, unreliable, often malicious. There are moments of astonishing reality in the presentation of these characters; the play’s opening with Big Sis and Big Sue is a study in superb character-driven dialog, a moody preamble to a calamitous narrative. Green’s former slaves are all presented in the manner one would expect from the era in which he writes: servile, cunning, prone to steal, the women eager to seduce white men, the men shiftless, shirking what we are led to think of as their duties to the family they serve. Green has not resolved the ideas of white supremacy with which he was surely raised, and his consciousness is not pioneering toward a prediction of the civil rights era.
But with his storyteller’s instinct he has reached the core of the Southern dilemma. White people and black people never could keep their hands off one another. There is no more tacit admission of equality than desire. The great dynasty of Connelly was built on a corrupt falsehood, a notion of property that reduced human beings to exploitable chattel, a lie maintained by a separation of the races that could never be sustained. (In making this assertion, I am presuming that there were regular instances of consensual relations between blacks and whites; I am fully aware that much of the sex forced by whites on blacks is better described as an expression of power than of desire.)
This is an honesty that, even if partly accidental, buttresses the play with the certainty that it has touched something essential. Green’s drama helps us to see that the story of the South cannot be staged with slavery and its repercussions politely concealed behind a backdrop of charm and oddity. Relations between black and white are not the subtext of Southern art; they are its core. Tapping into this furnace of dramatic energy, Green created a play so disturbing that the Group Theater forced him to write a more palatable ending. Before Bauer told me the tale, I would not have believed this legendary theater could be so cowed by the drama it craved to produce.
I am grateful to have encountered this play, and believe, as does Bauer, that it should take a place among much better known works in the Southern canon. Green was a seminal force in early twentieth-century American theater and deserves to be understood as the forebear of later Southern writers. The House of Connelly comes down to us as a raw, powerful example of what a playwright can do when tracing the course of tragedy through our complacent ideas of the past. The Connelly family stands as a fierce depiction of the power of the past, and a true portrait of the landscape of white supremacy and its hypocrisy.